Just over a year after 360 inmates of a Honduras prison and two visitors were killed in a fire, there is still no justice for the families of those who died.
On 14 February 2012 a blaze tore through the Comayagua jail where more than 800 people were held in a facility designed for around 500. Over half of the inmates held that night were still awaiting trial, according to a report sent to the United Nations by the Honduran government and seen by the Associated Press.
Despite promises in the immediate aftermath of a full and transparent investigation, and international shock at the scale of the loss of life, the investigation into the fire remains open, with no criminal charges of negligence brought against prison or government officials.
Reports at the time highlighted how firefighters were unable to gain access to the fire as they didn’t have keys to get past the prison bars.
A report last week from the Associated Press on the anniversary of the fire highlighted the scale of the errors that led to so many perishing.
Prosecutor German Enamorado explained some of the findings of the Government’s Office of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives. He said that the fire began with
…a flame in one of the cells that spread in a few minutes… But there was negligence on the part of authorities in charge of prison security, whose actions could have avoided a death toll of this magnitude…
There was no mechanism to extinguish fires, no evacuation plan. The firefighters were not allowed to get there quickly and the guards, instead of acting appropriately, only fired shots in the air, supposedly because that is the established procedure in case of escapes.
In a video report from Al Jazeera we are shown the shower facilities in which 80 people all perished — it is presumed they were trying to seek shelter from the fire under the shower heads.
Any compensation for relatives of those who died in the Comayagua jail fire is only likely to be paid after the official investigation has concluded its report.
Prison fire safety policies
The duality of prisoner safety and prison security is something that we’ve written about previously with the Ministry of Justice in the UK telling us last year that it has “robust measures” in place to deal with prison fires.
While prisons are justifiably unwilling to comment on their specific arrangements, government advice documents detail the types of measures that prisons are supposed to take in order to be compliant with the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005.
Recommendations include aligning the fire safety policy of a high-security facility with health and safety policies by making it the responsibility of the health and safety officer.
The guidance also identifies prisoners as “people who are especially at risk” alongside young people, parents with babies, the elderly and infirm, and people with disabilities.
The risk assessments and guidance should be reviewed annually and whenever there is an outbreak of fire or a failure of any kind in the fire detection systems used.
There is also additional guidance for procedures should a fire break out in a cell, including that people should “carry out a dynamic risk assessment before entering a cell where a fire is in progress and the information from this assessment used to make decisions on appropriate action.”
There is also specific advice on the use of breathing apparatus or a smoke hood, presumably envisaged for prison officials to use when checking a burning cell for inmates.
These systems are evidently rigorous, but the scale of the Honduran tragedy came about chiefly as a result of chronic overcrowding — a problem that prisons the world over are facing.
Download the Fire Safety in 2023 eBook, keeping you up to date with the biggest news and prosecution stories from around the industry. Chapters include important updates such as the Fire Safety (England) Regulations 2022 and an overview of the new British Standard for the digital management of fire safety information.
Plus, we explore the growing risks of lithium-ion battery fires and hear from experts in disability evacuation and social housing.
Its so unfortunate that despite the elaspe of one year the investigation has not reached any conclusive end. The huge number of inmates (360) indicates that the prison was overcrowded and stuffed more than its capacity. The authorities responsible for making it overcrowded are still not being asked about such dereliction of duty. It’s a fact the penitentiaries all across the world do not follow the desired standards but some reasonable facility is deserved by these humans. Its such a pity that prison did not have any fire evacution systems or alarm that could warn the authorities. Neither, fire fighter… Read more »
Agreed – learning from tragedies such as this is crucial. To be fair to the Government, they have at least apparently sourced $60m to build a new prison at Comayagua. But in the AP report I linked to we also hear about a prison built as recently as 2007 with no running water. Bizarre.