Avatar photo

Author Bio ▼

IFSEC Insider, formerly IFSEC Global, is the leading online community and news platform for security and fire safety professionals.
April 12, 2023

Sign up to free email newsletters


The Video Surveillance Report 2022

Association news

BSIA calls on Health & Safety Executive to reduce financial burden over ‘counterproductive’ accreditation schemes

The British Security Industry Association (BSIA), is calling on the Health & Safety Executive (HSE) to review current commercial safety schemes that are affecting its members’ ability to remain competitive.

BSIA-HSEsafetyschemes-23Concerns have been raised around the time consuming and administratively costly processes often used as a barrier to entry on prospective customer sites, requiring an organisation to acquire and maintain multiple accreditations for the same management system and paying for the privilege.

Prospective customers are pinning their colours to one scheme and not accepting other equally valid schemes, even though they are assessing the same management system.

Based on feedback from its members, the BSIA believes there is ambivalence over whether these schemes are delivering on health and safety goals, with scant evidence of any tangible positive impact directly attributed to these schemes.

The BSIA has identified that the current safety schemes seem counterproductive, bureaucratic, and costly to many organisations for the following reasons:

  • These schemes are more concerned about customer preference, dependent upon the procurement policy of their system.
  • Full management system (third party) UKAS certifications, such as ISO 45001 are being devalued and are not accepted by prospective customers.
  • Prospective customers see this as passing some of their health and safety responsibility (and all due diligence) onto others, with no need for due diligence on sub-contractors.
  • These accreditations detract from genuine safety performance as recognised by such bodies as the Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents.

Steve Lampett, Technical Manager, BSIA, said: “The Association believes the abundance of commercial safety schemes has turned accreditation into a huge bureaucratic system; a box ticking exercise with little to do with genuine health and safety assessment, which is, according to the Safety Schemes in Procurement website, supported by the HSE.

“Whilst the industry is keen to demonstrate best practice and is a passionate champion of health and safety and accepts its requirement for independent assessment, we believe these accreditations have had no positive impact on safety and are not working as intended. We are therefore calling on the HSE to review their support for these schemes in line with our members’ valid concerns.”


Register today for IFSEC 2023

16-18 May 2023, ExCeL London | IFSEC 2023: Recognising the past, embracing the future

Join thousands of likeminded security and risk professionals at IFSEC 2023 in May, as the UK's largest and longest running security event looks ahead to what's next in the sector as it celebrates its 50th birthday. This year will see the launch of the IFSEC distributor network, while London's new Elizabeth Line makes travel to the venue easier than ever!

You’ll find hundreds of leading exhibitors from the physical and integrated security sector, showcasing all the latest in video surveillance, access control, intruder detection, perimeter protection and software solutions. Join the community and secure your ticket today!


Related Topics

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments