Adam Bannister

Editor, IFSEC Global

Author Bio ▼

Adam Bannister is editor of IFSEC Global. A former managing editor at Dynamis Online Media Group, he has been at the helm of the UK's leading fire and security publication since 2014.
January 24, 2017

Get the SHP newsletter

The latest health and safety news

Download

Access control in the Asia-Pacific 2017: Legacy infrastructure, innovation and the Internet of Things

News

Met police blasted for “abysmal” record on CCTV image collection

The Met police has an abysmal record when it comes to collecting CCTV images to aid prosecutions, their former CCTV chief has claimed.

Mick Neville, head of the Met’s Central Forensic Image Team until he retired two weeks ago, says the Met’s super recognisers – people with an exceptional talent for recognising faces – could solve thousands more crimes if the force trained officers to understand how to retrieve and use footage from London’s myriad network of video surveillance systems.

“The Met has the best system in the world for identifying suspects who are caught on camera in connection with crimes but it is not getting the images,” he said. “All these cameras are on and capturing images of suspects, but they are not being used to anything like their full potential.”

CCTV images were used in less than 2% of criminal cases in London during an eight month period last year, he said. This is despite the hug coverage afforded by the capital’s CCTV systems, with the average Briton caught on camera 70 times a day.

Of 515,193 crimes recorded by the Met between April and November, 84,035 offences were solved, including 1,629 with the help of CCTV. CCTV images were filed in 9,745 cases. Only 64 robberies were solved using CCTV footage out of 1,515 where images were retrieved (there were 15,330 robberies in total).

met police blasted

“Complex”

Neville said that officers were not routinely trained in image retrieval or given the tools necessary to download surveillance files from a “myriad of complex CCTV systems which even the owner did not understand.

“If the Met had specialist teams to gather and investigate images they could solve thousands more crimes. I think the Met is letting Londoners down. At present, officers have no training or equipment, or incentive, to gather CCTV in any but the most serious crimes.

“However, we know that there are certain people, a small number, committing a lot of volume crime. By gathering more images the super recognisers could do a lot more.

“Billions of pounds are being spent in London on CCTV, but we are only collecting images of 1.9% of crimes. That is abysmal. We are trading our privacy for security, but we are not actually getting the benefit.”

The former detective said he issued a similar warning in 2008 but that his message went unheeded.

“The key issue here is getting the CCTV footage to the police quickly. Unfortunately, most CCTV isn’t easily accessible.” James Wickes, CEO, Cloudview

James Wickes, CEO and co-founder of Cloudview, says the security industry could make it easier, and quicker, for police to get the images they need. “The key issue here is getting the CCTV footage to the police quickly,” he said. “Unfortunately most CCTV isn’t easily accessible.”

“Someone has to go to where the recording device is located, find the relevant footage and then put it onto a disk or USB stick so the police can collect it. If they can’t get the footage off the system, the police frequently end up taking the entire DVD recorder!

“And all too often the user gets to the site only to find that their cameras are out of order. I’d estimate that only around 1-2% of CCTV is being used.

“A much better solution is to store CCTV footage in the cloud. It can be accessed instantly if it’s needed, and emailed directly to the police so they can look at it immediately – a much better use of their resources – and taxpayers’ money – than having to go and collect it first.

“Another advantage is that criminals often damage or destroy CCTV equipment, so using cloud means that the evidence is out of reach, except by those authorised to access it.”

Neville’s comments were also seized on by Big Brother Watch chief executive Renate Samson: “We are one of the most watched cities in the world but as these comments reveal we may be sacrificing our privacy to a system which is providing very little security,” he said.

“Whilst we are told CCTV prevents crime, these figures indicate that crimes are ongoing and that CCTV is only used to investigate crime which has already happened.  We have lived with these cameras for over 15 years now. Isn’t it time we were told the truth about how they used, where they provide value and whether they are truly necessary to be everywhere we go?”

A recent independent review recommended that the Met’s renowned super recognisers, who helped German police identify suspects following a coordinated spate of assaults in Cologne on New Year’s Eve 2015-16, should be doubled in number. Just six recognisers currently contribute to the arrest of around 100 suspects a week.

Neville also pointed out that more suspects are identified via facial recognition than through DNA detections.

 

Visit Europe’s leading security event in June 2017

Visit IFSEC International for exclusive access to every security product on the market, live product demonstrations and networking with thousands of security professionals.

From access control and video surveillance to smart buildings, cyber, border control and so much more. It is the perfect way to keep up to date, protect your business and enhance your career in the security industry.  

Click here
to register your place now to join us at London Excel on 20 – 22 June 2017.

Leave a Reply

7 Comments on "Met police blasted for “abysmal” record on CCTV image collection"

Notify of
avatar
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Allevate
Guest
Additionally, the Facewatch (http://www.facewatch.co.uk) online crime reporting system could be instrumental here. A large % of UK police forces already let businesses digitally file crime reports online using Facewatch, including the ability for these business to digitally upload the digital imagery as evidence. No more need for the police to physically collect the imagery. Additionally, when integrated with Allevate’s Face-searcher service (http://allevate.com/index.php/facesearcher/) , these same business take take full advantage of “in-the-cloud face recognition services” integrated with their Facewatch system, alerting them in real-time of possible sightings of individuals in their watchlists on their premises. Now, there’s putting the CCTV… Read more »
Mick Neville
Guest

Adam – thanks for referring to my comments.  This is a MASSIVE problem.   I have now set up my own consultancy – Neville Forensic Recognition Ltd to advise CCTV companies, law enforcement agencies, CCTV users, businesses, security etc on improving use of footage.  If anyone wishes to contact me whilst my website is being built, use mrmikeneville@aol.com

Simon Flude
Guest

Simon Flude  Simon Flude

Simon Flude
Guest

Simon Flude
The only justification for having so many cameras pointed at us all the time is that they can prevent and solve crime. 
CCTV images are not truncheons, to be used as a last resort, they should be `front-line` tools in the fight against crime.
I
appreciate that obtaining appropriate images used to be complex and
time consuming. Where it still is, those responsible should be looking
at the automated systems that already exist to make image backed crime
reporting a simple task.I know of one such system, `Facewatch` and, no doubt, there are others.

Doktor Jon
Guest
The problems of police use of CCTV were indeed first highlighted by DCI Mick Neville almost a decade ago, and in an interview I conducted with him back in 2009, quite some detail was provided on his thoughts and suggestions concerning this vital aspect of CCTV work. The world has of course moved on somewhat since then, but in one respect at least not a lot has changed. Against a backdrop of financial constraints in policing, and a lack of specialist Forensic Surveillance officers, now more than ever the primary responsibility is for CCTV Users and Operators to manage their… Read more »
Adam Bannister
Guest

Mick Neville No problem, Mick. Thank you for raising the issue! It’s certainly troubling to think of the incredible amount of technology out there essential being wasted (deterrence aside).

morten tor nielsen
Guest
Storing things in the cloud is no panacea, and not something that can or will solve the immediate problem. Consider the following scenario: A man is robbed in a dark alley. There are no recordings from the crime itself, but there are 21 cameras in the near vicinity. Which of those 21 cameras have decent footage that can be used to identify the assailant. You may know that the crime took place at 03:14 am, but if the assailant was waiting in the alley, what time did he arrive there?  So now you are looking for a guy that is… Read more »
wpDiscuz
Topics: